
German stocks continue to fall, but the bears are not taking profits. Goldberg sees new reference points.
The DAX has fallen again, commentators seem to agree that the interim high is over. Local, medium-term oriented investors have hardly reacted. Of the professionals, 4 per cent have gone long without a position, of the private investors, 3 per cent have taken bearish profits and moved to the sidelines. Sentiment remains poor at -18 and -21 points.
Joachim Goldberg is surprised that so few bears have cashed out. They should have already seen their entry prices. The behavioural economist suspects shifted reference points. One tends to orient oneself to the year's lows below today's level. Supporting demand could come from there, should it continue to go down. However, Goldberg does not see a turning point.
31 August 2022 FRANKFURT (Frankfurt Stock Exchange). Even since our last sentiment survey, the stream of negative news for equity markets has not diminished. Whether it was the continuation of rising interest rates in the USA announced by Fed Chairman Jerome Powell at the meeting of central bankers in Jackson Hole at the end of last week or the record high gas and electricity prices in this country and the associated general upward pressure on prices - the DAX lost around 4.6 per cent of its value at times from its highest point during the reporting period. Seen in this light, the DAX's weekly loss of 1.4 per cent (in point terms) seems almost harmless in view of inflation fears and the call by some voices from the ECB Governing Council for rapid and robust key interest rate hikes. But in hindsight, the summer rally from mid-July to mid-August, which many disliked, has long since come to an end, according to many commentators.
A falling DAX was also anticipated by the majority of institutional investors with a medium-term trading horizon we surveyed. After all, our Börse Frankfurt Sentiment Index has meanwhile risen by 3 points to a new level of -18. However, this is not because the number of pessimists has decreased - on balance it has even increased minimally. The slight improvement in sentiment is rather due to some formerly neutral players who have turned to the bull side in view of the falling market. However, we are only talking about an increase of 4 percentage points among the optimists.
Still no profit taking
The mood among private investors has also improved slightly, as our Börse Frankfurt Sentiment Index also rose by 3 points to a new level of -20 in this panel. This gain is almost entirely due to profit-taking by former pessimists who have covered back their bearish exposures.
With today's survey, the sentiment scores of private and institutional investors still remain quite close to each other. In both groupings, it is noticeable that the bears continue to hold back on the bottom line with profit-taking, although for most the exposure underlying their sentiment may have been profitable by now.
There are probably two reasons for this restraint. It is possible that the corresponding bearish positions are comparatively small in terms of volume and do not matter in terms of performance. It is more likely, however, that the bulk of the pessimists expect more trouble for the financial markets. And what the pessimists might expect from the stock market in the negative sense, or perhaps secretly hope for, is shown by a look at a DAX chart: already three times this year, lows have been marked at similarly low levels. The lowest of these is at around 12,391 DAX points, the highest at 12,439.
Shifted reference points
In other words, in view of this almost seductively favourable "buying opportunity", these reference points seem to be perceived more as orientation markers than other reference points (such as the pessimists' cost prices) due to their better visibility. A phenomenon that behavioural finance subsumes under the term availability heuristic.
Thus, possible demand by pessimistic investors near the lows of the year to date could put a stop to the downward trend of the DAX, at least in the short term - it is, however, very questionable whether this could result in a turning point towards a longer-term positive development.
31 August 2022, © Goldberg & Goldberg for boerse-frankfurt.de

| Bullish | Bearish | Neutral | |
| Total | 31% | 49% | 20% |
Compared to last survey | +4% | +1% | -5% |
DAX (Change to last survey): 12.920 (-190 points)
Börse Frankfurt Sentiment index institutional investors: -18 points (Status last survey: -21 points)

| Bullish | Bearish | Neutral | |
| Total | 29% | 49% | 22% |
| Compared to last survey | +0% | -3% | +3% |
DAX (Change to last survey): 12.920 (-190 points)
Börse Frankfurt Sentiment index private investors: -20 points (Status last survey: -23 points)
